Showing posts with label hyphen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hyphen. Show all posts

Monday, March 26, 2012

Order By ignoring the hyphen character

Hi,
I'm using the following SQL script to return a list of part number and the order is not what I expect. Perhaps this is a collation problem but I have no idea where to look to modify that.

Thanks in advance, John
select part from transactions T where (T.transdate between '20070701' and '20070705') and
(T.transtype = 'ISSU' or T.transtype = 'RTRN') order by part

Here is the beginning of the Transactions table create script

CREATE TABLE [Transactions] (
[RecNo] [int] IDENTITY (1,1) NOT NULL,
[Part] [nvarchar] (30) NOT NULL ,
[TransDate] [nvarchar] (8) NOT NULL ,
[TransType] [nvarchar] (4) NOT NULL ,
[FromLoc] [nvarchar] (10) ,

The 'Part' column is an alphanumeric field. The problem I am having is that the
Order By seems to ignore the hyphen character '-' when the returned rows
are ordered by the Part (which can contain hyphens in any column).

Here is an example of what I get.

130909N9
130909N9
130909N9
1-480698-0 * These two should not be here
1-480699-0 *
15-423
164-07700
164-07700
164-07700
1683
I was expecting this ( and I get this in and older database ).

068-03000
068-03000
06A19956
074-03200
077-367-0
08DU08
1-480698-0 * These should be here eariler in the data
1-480699-0
100-364072
100-364072

It is by design. http://support.microsoft.com/kb/305704

What about using another column for sorting?

SELECT part, replace(part,'-','00000') as partForSortingHyphen

FROM Transactions

ORDER BY partForSortingHyphen ASC

|||Thanks,
Your suggusted workaround did the trick.
John
sql

Order By ignoring the hyphen character

Hi,
I'm using the following SQL script to return a list of part number and the order is not what I expect. Perhaps this is a collation problem but I have no idea where to look to modify that.

Thanks in advance, John
select part from transactions T where (T.transdate between '20070701' and '20070705') and
(T.transtype = 'ISSU' or T.transtype = 'RTRN') order by part

Here is the beginning of the Transactions table create script

CREATE TABLE [Transactions] (
[RecNo] [int] IDENTITY (1,1) NOT NULL,
[Part] [nvarchar] (30) NOT NULL ,
[TransDate] [nvarchar] (8) NOT NULL ,
[TransType] [nvarchar] (4) NOT NULL ,
[FromLoc] [nvarchar] (10) ,

The 'Part' column is an alphanumeric field. The problem I am having is that the
Order By seems to ignore the hyphen character '-' when the returned rows
are ordered by the Part (which can contain hyphens in any column).

Here is an example of what I get.

130909N9
130909N9
130909N9
1-480698-0 * These two should not be here
1-480699-0 *
15-423
164-07700
164-07700
164-07700
1683
I was expecting this ( and I get this in and older database ).

068-03000
068-03000
06A19956
074-03200
077-367-0
08DU08
1-480698-0 * These should be here eariler in the data
1-480699-0
100-364072
100-364072

It is by design. http://support.microsoft.com/kb/305704

What about using another column for sorting?

SELECT part, replace(part,'-','00000') as partForSortingHyphen

FROM Transactions

ORDER BY partForSortingHyphen ASC

|||Thanks,
Your suggusted workaround did the trick.
John